Are you struggling to fit fruits and vegetables into your daily routine?
The greens powder market is flooded with products that claim to not only provide your nutritional needs but also take care of your energy, immune system, gut support, and even your weight management.
Over the years, many products have entered and left brick-and-mortar stores and online retailers, but two stand out among the best:
Athletic Greens and Organifi.
Both companies are devoted to bringing customers a fresh approach to green powder and green juice through their respective companies, but figuring out which one to buy can be tricky.
After all, not every green supplement is the same, right?
In this detailed guide, we’ll compare Athletic Greens vs. Organifi so you can determine which brand is right for your goals.
Note: this post contains affiliate links. So, we get a small commission at no extra cost to you if you purchase.
Organifi vs. Athletic Greens: A Quick Comparison
Organifi | Athletic Greens | |
Featured Ingredients | – Wheat Powder – Matcha – Chlorella – Coconut Water – Turmeric – Ashwagandha | – Spirulina – Chlorella – Grape Seed Extract – Antioxidant Extract – Reishi Mushroom – Bark Powder – Lactobacillus acidophilus |
Benefits Claims | – Energy – Immunity Support – Stress Relief – Weight Management | – Energy – Digestive Health – Immunity Support – Nervous System Support |
Customer Feedback | – 4.9/5 (website) – 4.3/5 (Amazon) – Pros: Mixes well, great taste, good energy – Cons: Rather high cost, results are not immediate | – 4.5/5 (website) – 4.6/5 (Amazon) – Pros: Plenty of daily energy, helps with digestion – Cons: Average taste, ingredients need to be considered |
Price Points | – One-time Purchase: $69.95 – Monthly Subscription: $62.96 | – The Pouch: $99 – Travel Packs: $109 – Monthly Subscription: $79-169 |
Organifi Overview
Company
A company’s strength depends on its ability to adapt, modify, and reinvent itself for the betterment of its customers.
Organifi is a strong example of this concept by having 52 iterations of its signature green juice product.
They believe in “empowering through individual wellness” through their products, recipe guides, nutrition coaching, and the community they’ve created to support their members.
Organifi markets itself by using plant-based whole food blends that are certified organic and glyphosate residue-free, giving customers a sense of assurance with their products. They also manufacture out of FDA-compliant facilities.
To give back to the communities they serve, Organifi turns its efforts to reduce its carbon footprint with sugarcane canisters that capture carbon dioxide.
Products
Organifi offers a wealth of nutritional products on its website. This includes red juice, green juice, protein powder, immune support supplements, gold powder, and more. For the sake of comparison, we’ll stick with their signature green juice.
Organifi’s green juice is made for “body rest and stress support” and meticulously designed with eleven superfoods to achieve your healthcare goals.
Their Green Juice comes in a few varieties based on flavor and size.
The Original Mint has a canister size with thirty 9.3g scoop servings and in travel packs of thirty 9.3g servings.
The Crisp Apple flavor comes in a canister size with the same serving sizes and numbers but is not currently available in travel packs.
Ingredients
As mentioned, Organifi has gone through an extensive process with their products such as the Green Juice. Their plant-based ingredients are USDA-certified organic with each product batch going through multiple rounds of third-party testing.
In addition, Organifi relies on low-temperature drying in a chemical-free gentle process, meaning that they do not use raw blends.
The Green Juice has a diverse list of ingredients including wheat powder, moringa powder, spirulina powder, chlorella, matcha green tea, coconut water, monk fruit extract, turmeric extract, a prebiotic blend, and natural flavors like orange.
However, it does not have a probiotic blend, as you’ll notice later with AG1.
Benefits
Like many green powders and green juices, the primary benefit of adding this supplement to your daily routine is the additional vegetable content you might normally miss, which includes the vitamins and minerals each ingredient provides.
However, Organifi goes deeper with their claims by saying that the Green Juice provides stress relief, better sleep, immune system support, and natural energy.
Organifi Green Juice does have trace amounts of caffeine due to the matcha green tea powder.
That along with increased energy from spirulina are both backed by clinical studies for both ingredients.
Turmeric has long been considered an aid for immune support, and this green juice has this vital ingredient in spades.
There are also studies that support the usage of ashwagandha (also in the ingredient list) as helping for white blood cell production and stress relief.
However, not every ingredient has had enough strenuous research to back up its claims.
Wheatgrass, for example, has mild backing for claims of inflammation reduction.
There’s also the factor of how much of each ingredient is in each serving, which can make these health claims more of a long-term endeavor instead of somewhat immediate.
Reviews
The Organifi website lists their popular Green Juice with an astonishing 4.9 out of 5 rating based on 2,862 reviews as of this writing. While most likely curated, that’s an impressive figure to feature. Amazon has a more moderate rating of 4.3 out of 5 from 9,096 reviews.
However, what do customers say about this product?
Fans by and large love the flavors of both the Original Mint and Crispy Apple varieties.
They also like the smooth energy boost through the day, the fact that it mixes well in both hot and cold liquids, and its usefulness for those who often feel malnourished.
Critics of the Organifi Green Juice are skeptical of the high product cost (more on that in a second), some mild discomfort from the caffeine content, and the fact that results take a while to accumulate.
Price
With the canister and travel packs having the same servings and serving size, the price for either version is the same.
Right now, Organifi is offering their signature Green Juice for $69.95 for a one-time purchase.
They are also offering a monthly subscription for either package for $62.96 a month.
As an interesting point, they do allow customers to make four interest-free payments instead of paying a lump sum for the product.
Athletic Greens Overview
Company
Founded in 2009, this New Zealand-based nutrition company has rebranded themselves to AG1 and with it a fresh approach to green powder supplements. They still retain a motto to “bring comprehensive and convenient daily nutrition to just about everybody.”
If you’re looking for a company that’s highly credentialed, then look no further. AG1 is NSF Certified and manufactures out of a Therapeutic Goods Administration (TGA) registered facility, giving you quality assurance.
In addition, AG1 is also focused on sustainability. Their efforts to make the world a greener place include their smart labeling for products to ensure better recycling and being Climate Neutral Certified.
Products
Before the switch to the AG1 brand, Athletic Greens provided a litany of products on their website and Amazon centered on wellness, including comprehensive powders, Omega-3 fish oil supplements, and D3+K2 drops.
These items are still featured on Amazon in the previous packaging, but since the rebranding to AG1, the company has narrowed their scope to green powder.
They now offer two major products: a thirty-serving size pouch (affectionately called The Pouch) or a package of thirty individual serving packs (called the Travel Packs).
For both products, a single serving is 12g.
Ingredients
AG1 boasts an impressive 75 vitamins, minerals, and nutrients in their signature products, giving you a well-rounded approach to your nutritional needs.
Every ingredient and batch goes through an extensive vetting process based on TGA and NSF standards.
AG1 notes their strenuous review process by revealing that their recipe has been revised 52 times.
Among the abundance of ingredients in AG1 Green Powder include alkaline, a nutrient-dense superfood complex with spirulina, chlorella, broccoli, pineapple fruit concentrate, bark powder, and herb and antioxidant extracts.
For added digestive support, the products contain a super mushroom complex and the probiotic strains Lactobacillus acidophilus and Bifidobacterium bifidum.
Benefits
AG1’s green powder products are said to help with energy, gut health, and immune system support among other claims.
While there are no current clinical studies on AG1 as of this writing, there’s plenty of research on individual ingredients found in their products and the corresponding benefits.
For example, chlorella has been studied for its ability to help regulate blood sugar, and AG1 appears to have enough of this ingredient per serving to make a difference.
The two probiotic strains in the green powder also have research backing up the claims to promote stronger gut health.
On the other hand, there’s still some ambiguity about whether or not other major ingredients in the green powder are at high enough levels to cause their proposed benefits.
Nevertheless, customers who purchase AG1 can find themselves a healthy way to have energy and a more balanced diet.
Reviews
Between their official website and the current listings on Amazon, AG1 has a wealth of feedback from customers. The website lists the company broadly at 4.5 out of 5 stars based on over 20,000 reviews.
On Amazon, the reviews are split based on The Pouch (4.5 out of 5 from over 3,004 reviews) or the Travel Packs (4.6 out of 5 from 909 reviews), though these appear to be prior to the rebranding to AG1 from Athletic Greens.
Fans of this product have said that they enjoy sustained energy throughout the day (especially to start the morning), better digestion and gut health, and even lower cholesterol levels in a few instances.
On the other hand, criticisms were mainly relegated to the fact that the taste needs improvement. Some critics have also said that the suggested benefits were not happening as fast as they anticipated.
Finally, the extensive ingredient list means that customers will have to be thorough to check what’s in each serving versus any allergens or negative reactions they may encounter should they use it.
Price
With new branding comes a new approach to buying, and AG1 is no exception.
The Pouch is available to purchase for $99 for a one-time purchase or via a monthly subscription model for $79 (one container) or $149 (two containers).
The Travel Packs can be bought online with a one-time purchase at $109, a monthly subscription for $89 for two packages, and a double subscription for $169 per month.
Athletic Greens vs. Organifi Green Juice: Comparing the Things That Matter
After looking at both Organifi and Athletic Greens, it’s time to figure out which one is the superior greens supplement. To do that, we’ll look at the following factors:
Ingredients
Both AG1 and Organifi have a plethora of plant-based ingredients. In fact, there’s some crossover between the two with spirulina and chlorella.
However, those similarities start to diverge as you look at each product’s nutrition label.
Organifi relies mainly on low-temperature ingredients that are turned into a powder, leaving the rest to be extracts like ashwagandha and red beetroot.
AG1, on the other hand, is more diverse with its mushroom complex, bark powder, and probiotic strains, meaning that you’re getting additional benefits that Organifi doesn’t offer – at least to the same degree.
It’s a close comparison, but AG1 edges this section out.
Reviews
Organifi and AG1 are highly popular on their respective websites and on Amazon.
It’s interesting to note that while Organifi is more popular on its own site, AG1 has more positive feedback on Amazon (though this could be carried over from their days as Athletic Greens).
While Organifi had more customers remarking that they liked the taste of their products, AG1 had less people criticizing the price of their green powder despite being priced higher.
Both received pushback on the fact that the suggested benefits for each took some time to happen, yet both were praised for how well they mixed.
This is a tie.
Price
Finally, the factor that immediately catches your eye in the supermarket and online: the price.
AG1 is notably the more expensive product, both in The Pouch and in the Travel Packs with a difference of around $30 and $40 respectively compared to Organifi’s one-time purchase.
AG1 and Organifi both have subscription models for their popular products that narrow the price gap between the two.
Yet AG1 has more variety with their subscription models between the package type you can choose (The Pouch or the Travel Packs) and the amount you can purchase per subscription.
That indicates that AG1 believes that customers who purchase their green powder want to have the next batch ready to go without having to go through the hassle of reordering again.
This is a sign of both confidence and quality assurance despite the higher price point compared to Organifi.
Organifi wins this round due to math.
Organifi vs. Athletic Greens: The Verdict
Organifi and Athletic Greens are both incredible products to purchase if your health goals are based on better nutrition and long-term success.
They are similar in their approach to delivering plant-based ingredients to consumers in an economical manner with plenty of fans on both sides.
In the end, we believe AG1 to be the superior product based on its unique ingredients.
Does that mean that Organifi should not be purchased? Absolutely not.
This product is a great way to fit your nutritional needs throughout the day, sustain natural energy, and work towards better immune support.
Ideal customers are those who want a greens-based product with a friendlier price point without the need to dive into a subscription model to save money.
No matter which one you choose, your path toward a healthier happier you starts with a sip of something green in the morning.